Stewartstown, PA 17363 37 High Street

OPEN HOUSE Sat, Jul 18 2026 1:00 PM - 3:00 PM
37 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 137 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 237 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 3
27 more
37 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 437 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 537 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 637 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 737 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 837 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 937 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1037 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1137 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1237 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1337 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1437 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1537 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1637 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1737 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1837 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 1937 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2037 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2137 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2237 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2337 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2437 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2537 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2637 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2737 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2837 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 2937 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 3037 High Street Stewartstown, PA - Image 31
Presented By: Keller Williams Legacy
  • MLS# PAYK2106416
  • 06/26/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 4
  • Full/Half Baths • 2 / 1
  • SQFT • 2,580
  • Garage • 2

Home Details

Nestled on just under 3/4 of an acre in the heart of Stewartstown, this beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath colonial is packed with modern farmhouse charm and custom details throughout. Step onto the completely redone front porch featuring composite decking built to last, and into a stunning first floor with brand-new luxury vinyl plank flooring. The upgraded kitchen boasts granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a large center island; open to a spacious dining area and sitting room with coffered ceilings. Relax in the inviting living room anchored by a striking stone gas fireplace with reclaimed wood accent walls and original wood floors. A convenient first-floor laundry completes the main level. Upstairs, the private owner's suite features a vaulted ceiling with reclaimed wood, custom sliding barn doors, a walk-in closet, en-suite bath, and access to a private balcony; perfect for morning coffee. Three additional generously sized bedrooms and a full bath with double sinks round out the second floor, while the finished third-level attic with closet offers flexible space for a 5th bedroom, home office, or playroom. Outside, the expansive, fully fenced backyard is an entertainer's dream, complete with a pool deck, patio, large workshop, detached 2-car garage, and storage shed. All of this with public utilities and central A/C, just a short walk to grocery stores, dining, and Stewartstown Elementary School. Easy access to I-83 makes commuting a breeze. This is truly a must-see!
Presented By: Keller Williams Legacy

Interior Features for 37 High Street

Bedrooms

Bedrooms Count All Upper Levels4
Bedrooms Count Upper Level 14
Main Level Bedrooms
Total Bedrooms4

Bathrooms

Bathrooms Half Main Level1
Bathrooms Full Upper Level 12
Bathrooms Full All Upper Levels2
Bathrooms Count Upper Level 12.00
Bathrooms Count All Upper Levels2
Half Baths1
Total Baths3

Other Interior Features

LivingAreaSourceEstimated
Above Grade Finished Area2580
Above Grade Finished Area SourceEstimated
Above Grade Finished Area Unit TypeSquare Feet
BasementPartial
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Central Air Y/NYes
Fireplace FeaturesGas/Propane
Fireplace Y/NYes
FlooringLuxury Vinyl Plank, Carpet
Heating FuelNatural Gas
Heating Y/NYes
Hot WaterNatural Gas
Laundry TypeMain Floor
Total Fireplaces1

General for 37 High Street

Acceptable FinancingCash, Conventional, FHA, VA
Accessibility2+ Access Exits
Architectural StyleColonial
Bathrooms Count Main Level1.00
Bathrooms Full Main Level
CitySTEWARTSTOWN
Condo/Coop Association fee Y/NNo
Construction MaterialsBrick
Cool FuelElectric
CoolingCentral A/C
CountyYORK
DirectionsFrom I83, Exit 4 - Follow Rt. 851 E to Stewartstown, left on Mill St., L on High St. to property on R.
Full Baths2
Garage Spaces2.00
Garage Y/NYes
HOANo
Heating90% Forced Air
Levels2
Living Area2580
Lot Size Square Feet31529.00
Lot Size UnitsSquare Feet
MLS AreaStewartstown Boro (15286)
MunicipalitySTEWARTSTOWN BORO
New ConstructionNo
Other StructuresAbove Grade
OwnershipFee Simple
Patio/Porch FeaturesBalcony, Patio(s)
PossessionSettlement
Price Per Sq Ft Total AG164.73
Property ConditionVery Good
Property TypeResidential
School DistrictSOUTH EASTERN
Senior Community Y/NNo
SewerPublic Sewer
Standard StatusActive
StatusACTIVE
Structure TypeDetached
Subdivision NameSTEWARTSTOWN BORO
Tax Annual Amount4025.0
Tax Assessed Value123280.0
Tax Year2026
Total SQFT2580
Vacation Rental Y/NNo
Water Access Y/NNo
Year Built1900
Year Built SourceEstimated
ZoningRESIDENTIAL TOWN

Exterior for 37 High Street

# of Detached Garage Spaces2
FencingSplit Rail
Foundation DetailsOther, Slab
Garage FeaturesGarage - Side Entry, Additional Storage Area, Oversized
Land Assessed Value34570.00
Lot Size Acres0.72
Lot Size SourceEstimated
Navigable Water Y/NNo
Parking FeaturesCrushed Stone, Asphalt Driveway
PoolNo Pool
Total Parking Spaces6
Type of ParkingDriveway, Detached Garage
Water Oriented Y/NNo
Water SourcePublic
Water View Y/NNo
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

Elementary School N/A
Middle School South Eastern Middle School
High School Kennard-Dale High School

Monica Hoover

Realtor
Price $425,000
MLS#PAYK2106416
List Date 06/26/2026
Property Type Single Family
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 37 High Street